Wednesday, August 4, 2010

Emerging Genre: New Adult Fiction

New Adult Fiction.

The elusive emerging genre in-between Young Adult and Adult Fiction.

Why it is called "New Adult" is beyond my knowledge, but here are some thoughts:

Have you ever read a book and knew the protagonist had been edited into a teenager for the purpose of categorising the novel into a sellable genre? The characters behave, speak, think and read more like twenty-year-old's, yet the novel is set in high school?
While trying to classify my own work in progress a few months ago (I grudgingly class it as "women's fiction") I stumbled across a couple of articles and blogs proclaiming the emergence of "New Adult". Today I asked the question on twitter if anyone knew if "new adult" was anything more than a pipe dream. The resulting conversations under new thread #newadultchat blew me away- so many writers and readers wanting to discuss this topic. The fact there are so many of us out there gives me hope that one day New Adult will be a genre reality.

The concept of fiction can be tricky, as to me, a part of yourself is in every story. When it comes to character driven stories (which I have discovered mine are) where the main character goes on an emotional quest rather than a physical one, a certain amount of your heart has to be in it for the emotion to be believable. Even in many thrillers, horrors, adventures, apocalyptic dystopians, a struggle of the heart keeps the reader emotionally invested in the characters plight.

To convey feeling, you the writer need to feel, and how we feel about situations, people and experiences, changes as we move from one stage of our life to the next. I feel I could write about a teenager, as I have been one, I could write about someone in their twenties because I am one. I don't feel I have the emotional maturity or psychological development to accurately story-tell about someone in their thirties, forties and beyond. Does this sound ridiculous? As I am talking about fiction, perhaps it does.

The idea of fiction may very well be to write about that which you do not know. For me writing about a fictional land or event is easier than writing about a fictional emotional reaction to the land or event. Because the land you create is always complete fiction. The FEELINGS are not. Everyone feels. The emotion in a novel can be an encyclopedia of feelings.

My MC is in her early twenties. She is not married. She doesn't have children. She isn't getting divorced. But she isn't a little girl either. She goes through some experiences from her late-teens INTO her twenties that are shaping her into a woman.

Nobody ever has it all figured out. Although there is a massive stereotype that the teen years are the years of self discovery, I will insist that this is not so! I personally remember the teens years just being bitchy and horrible- I don't think I discovered anything about myself. Whereas the years from 18-21, those three little years, changed me.




Between 18-21, wow- I just went through so much. Those years cause massive upheaval- and they are important! The changes to yourself, your life, career, family, friends, lovers, oh my! Nobody turns 18 and instantly finds everything that mattered when they were 17 no longer matters, like the young adult stops at 18, and now you suddenly know everything.

And nothing else seems to happen to you until you are in your thirties: finding a partner, getting divorced, changing careers, raising children. You know what? All that stuff happens when you're twenty as well! What- a career change isn't as big a deal in your twenties as in your thirties? Just because "oh you're still young enough to do that" doesn't mean it's not a big deal. Does getting married and having a baby in your twenties feel different than in your thirties? I don't know; I'm not thirty.

I don't know if when I'm in my thirties I will feel different about life, and love, and look back on my past differently. I am GUESSING that I will, as I already feel and think differently than I did five years ago when I was twenty. I already reflect back on things that I have been through in the past ten years and contemplate the past. How will ten more years change my perspective?

The twenties are an in-between. It is glaringly obvious that there is a massive gap between a 17 year old protagonist versus a 35 year old one. What is in-between?

I guess I just feel that taking experiences a twenty-something goes through and trying to say that a seventeen-year-old went through it, not only can create unbelievable characters, but also changes the feeling and emotion associated with it. The mental and emotional development of someone in their twenties is different from someone who is in high-school.

I think the same applies to characters in their thirties. I am 25, married, no children of my own, have a 17-year old step-son, a dog, a "day" job and I am desperately hoping to one day make a career out of writing. I have had loved ones come and go, have been through my own triumphs and tribulations. If I had been 35 when I got married and was bestowed the joys of a 17 year old step-son, would I have treated him differently? Would I have FELT different about the whole situation? Quite possibly.

I think I am trying to say that each stage of life is valid and important, and to try and give a teenage character the same experiences and emotions as someone ten years older than they are feels like it almost undermines the experiences had by a teenager- as those are important too. It changes the idea of how teenagers react to situations, emotions and people, and also impacts those EXPERIENCED by someone in their twenties. By the same token, I will NEVER pretend I know what it feels like to have 10 years on what I am now.
I hope that 10 years gives me knowledge, insight, understanding and wisdom- at least more than what I have now, and I will never undermine that LIFE EXPERIENCE by pretending I have already been there.

If I sound naive and unrealistically hopeful while writing this I actually think it further proves my point: the mind of twenty-somethings works different! The feelings are different! The level of KNOWLEDGE is different! We sound young because we are young- BUT we aren't 17 either. Don't insult the years we have been through by classifying us as big teenagers, and don't insult our older peers by saying we have been through everything they have. Because we haven't.


We haven't earned the right to speak as if we have been there and done it all. We haven't. But you know what? We are in it. Now. Can't I tell you about the journey?

22 comments:

  1. You make some very good points about the over 18 (less than 35) MC. My beta has similiar trouble with the ages of her characters so she's been following this "new adult" thing closely. Good luck!

    ~JD

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks Justine! It's kind of nice to know there are a few of us out there- it means maybe one day "new adult" may be real :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with Justine, some very brilliant points are being addressed here about ages in which you truly change as a person.

    I know a few people that issues with ages and I've heard that New Adult is really trying to break out of it's shell and make itself known. I hope that it does, it'd be nice to have a new shelf to turn to, I know a lot of books could be properly housed there!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I love those pics. This is a really interesting concept. Basically it feels like 16-18 is so idealized when really, the sixteen year olds in tv shows are played by actors in their twenties. They look like teens, sounds like teens. But they aren't teens. I guess the same could be said about these books where the characters are supposed to be teenagers but act like twenty year olds. In reality, the 16-18 year olds I knew (and was) weren't anywhere near that mature. A lot happens in the space of a few years.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Wow great points. I learnt so much between the ages of 18-21 too. Going to university, being away from my family. It taught me to grow up, and be independent in ways I couldn't have imagined.
    I think with teenage years, the struggle is trying to figure out who you are. Then, at 18-21 you start on that path.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I am crossing my fingers for New Adult. YES! I have read things that would have been better suited to a more mature, or at least older teen to early twenties character. You make a ton of valid points in this post and I HOPE for this new genre to peek out. There are so many writers I know that have had to sacrafice the age of thier characters because of the market and it killed them to do so. I am one of those writers. I finally decided to drop the age when I felt ready to write from that age but it is a story that I still clutch to as being one that is better suited to an early twenty-something. But now it's in teen mode because I'm still too young to write Adult properly.
    Lots of valid points and I really do hope this genre gains popularity. When I go to the bookstore I see more Adults in the YA section, so I have a feeling it's a market just ready to fly, because those are such important years of growth. All of them are, but that age range is where a lot of growth and "firsts" happen.
    Great post lovely Ali~

    ReplyDelete
  7. New Adult? I haven't heard that term. Your description and reasoning make sense though. As soon as I was out of high school, I did not want to read about people IN high school! We all relate to people who share the same life experiences. Interesting subject.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Great points - and I really enjoyed reading your take on this. I've not heard of this new adult fiction thing, so thanks for filling me in!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Just so we get away from calling these categories "genres" (those are novel, short story, poetry, theater, etc.) It doesn't do as a writer or as a book marketer to aim at thin demographics. A worthy piece of literature surely should appeal to readers of many different ages and readers should be willing to read about characters of all different ages.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Wow I am so overwhelmed by all you wonderful responses! All you guys are always so supportive of my blogs and your comments honestly give me such a high!

    Erica- I am so mortified and sorry you have had to change this story. This is EXACTLY why the market of New Adult needs to gain some momentum!

    I will be watching this trend so closely!

    I may have to do an international contest using BORDERS gift cards as bait to spread the word....

    ReplyDelete
  11. David- I completly agree with you!
    "A worthy piece of literature surely should appeal to readers of many different ages and readers should be willing to read about characters of all different ages." you are right.

    but all ages currently doesn't encompass the twenties. Just as Erica has had to do, I may have to lower my MC to high school age.

    ReplyDelete
  12. "I think with teenage years, the struggle is trying to figure out who you are. Then, at 18-21 you start on that path."

    Well said, Lindsay!

    I think the teenage years are all about striving to find your identity, where you fit into this big wide world and deciding what kind of person you want to become.

    18-21 (and maybe even a little beyond) is all about the dealing with the consequences of those choices you made in your teens. You're on this path you chose, but is it the right one? These are issues that don't work in an adult novel with an MC aged 30+.

    Life is a continuous journey, so let's hear about all aspects of this journey and not just the most popular stops along the way.

    xx a

    P.S. Brilliant post. New Adult all the way!

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thanks for the support Amber! *hugs*

    ReplyDelete
  14. Awesome post.

    I was told to age my MC down if I ever wanted to get an Agent. My MC was 18 and a freshman in college. Now I'm trying to writer her as a 17 year old in high school. We do what we have to right? I greatly look forward to New Adult catching on. We have a group on Writers Digest: YA/Crossover who are all in the same boat. If you're looking for support, beta readers, or just a place to vent drop by.

    ReplyDelete
  15. @Erica- sweet, will check out today after work :)

    @T-Romel- That is so sad! It really bums me out that you had to do that! I know what you mean- yes we do what we gotta do, doesn't mean we are happy about it or that it is the right thing... so sad!
    Oooh thanks for the tip! I will def jump on that train!

    ReplyDelete
  16. New Adult? I remember hearing about this at a writer's conference, and now seeing your post about the twitter hashtag makes me curious if if will gain in popularity. That would be interesting. My wip fits in that category as well - 18 yo protag.
    Have a great weekend!

    ReplyDelete
  17. @MT- yes it seems there are a few of us trying to break this awful restriction! I will be trying to post more about new adult to spread the work. maybe it will happen... :)

    ReplyDelete
  18. Ali--
    I've heard about this New Adult category and I hope it catches on because you're right. People out of high school, finding themselves in the "adult world" for the first time have very different experiences than teens in high school. And these are important experiences that shape them for the rest of their lives.

    Great Post :-)

    ReplyDelete
  19. thanks for your support koreen! :)

    ReplyDelete
  20. This really takes me back to so many questions I've had. (Our main characters have a lot in common, btw!!) I love what you said about our age changing our reactions to identical situations. I hope that I gain wisdom as I saunter into my thirties!! Amazing post!

    ReplyDelete
  21. Thanks Saumya! Your comments always make me smile! Let's hope there is a future for NA for all our sakes :)

    ReplyDelete